Order Cases Online
The files located in the Tennessee Supreme Court Cases represent an especially valuable resource for historical and genealogical research at the Tennessee State Library and Archives [TSLA].
Use quotes for an exact search. ex. "J. W."
View Entry | Year | Case Name | County | Cause/Crime | Case Description | Division | Location | # Pages | Order |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
View Entry | 1923 | Addie Harrell v. Fidelity Insurance Co. | Knox | Insurance Disputes |
Incomplete case file: testimony only. Because only testimony is present, case details are difficult to discern. It seems that Mrs. Addie Prince Harrell had trouble with her eyes, perhaps an astigmatism. She seems to have gotten into an accident, but was not badly harmed. She was diagnosed as neurasthenic. What she claimed to the insurance company is not stated here. Much questioning about glasses and nervous disorder. |
East | Range: 5 Section: B Shelf: Box Number: 13a | 328 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1891 | Alston Boyd v. Vanderbilt Mutual Insurance Company | Shelby | Insurance Disputes | West | Range: 83 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 326 | 91 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1899 | Annie G. Steele v. Endowment Bank Knights of Pythias | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Includes medical examiners certificate concluding J. K. Steel, deceased and plaintiff's husband in good health and therefore recommending membership to the order. J. K. Steel had $3,000.00 insurance policy through defendant. Upon his death widow would receive policy if he was in good standing. Also see WT Box 810 |
West | Range: 81 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 806 | 129 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1902 | Annie G. Steele v. Endowment Rank Knights of Pythias | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Two briefs only - no case file. Claimant is asking that her late husband's death benefits be paid to her as his survivor; the defendant claims that Mr. Steele violated the terms of the policy, which says it will not pay if death is caused by drugs, alcohol, or suicide. Also see WT Box 806 |
West | Range: 81 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 810 | 47 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1938 | Alice Houston v. Mutual Benefit Health & Accident Association | Cumberland | Insurance Disputes |
Deceased: Marschel H. Houston. |
East | Range: 7 Section: H Shelf: Box Number: 721 | 201 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1935 | Aetna Life Insurance Company v. J. Clarence Willis | Monroe | Insurance Disputes |
Willis worked for American Textile Woolen Co. and was insured by Aetna under a group policy. He became permanently injured in April 1932. Aetna refused to pay for his disability. Willis's original policy was submitted as evidence & is filed with case. |
East | Range: 8 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 850 | 71 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1891 | Alston Boyd v. Vanderbilt Mutual Insurance Company | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
File incomplete. Opinion only. See: WT, Box 326. Opinion filed in ET cases. |
East | Range: 19 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 1764 | 11 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1938 | Andy Hogue v. National Life & Accident Insurance Company | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes | East | Range: 7 Section: H Shelf: Box Number: 723 | 98 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1912 | A. H. Kortrecht, admr. of Henry Williams, dec. v. the Continental Casualty Company | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Henry Williams was accidentally killed in Obion, TN, 15 March 1907. Insurance failed to pay indemnity to his mother, Martha Williams. |
West | Range: 80 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 1083 | 110 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1934 | Amanda Combs v. National Life & Accident Insurance Company | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes |
The facts in this case are not entirely clear. However the case seems to involve a insurance policy for a John Henry Thomas in which Amanda Combs was named the beneficiary. |
East | Range: 8 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 849 | 20 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1931 | A. L. Bowman v. Home Insurance Company of New York | Decatur | Insurance Disputes |
Bowman had an insurance policy with the defendant for the loss by theft and fire of his automobile. The car was stolen but the insurance company refused to pay the claim. |
West | Range: 77 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 2036 | 74 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1917 | Annie L. Bond, admr. v. The National Life & Accident Insurance Company | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff is the administrator of the estate of Malinda E. Rhoten (dec.). sued for damages of $1,000 for when the defendant agreed to pay the deceased's beneficiaries $300 plus 10% for a time, resulting in a payout of $450. The defendant wrongfully declined to pay the beneficiaries any principle sums. |
West | Range: 79 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 1514 | 238 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1937 | Armster C. Crow v. Brotherhood of Locomotive Enginemen& Firemen | Unicoi | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff is a member of Lodge number 763 of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Enginemen and Firemen. Through this membership plaintiff purchased a beneficiary certificate of insurance worth $1500 protecting him against total disability. Plaintiff became totally and permanently disabled while covered under said policy but claims the defendant refuses to pay benefits. Exhibit material includes insurance policy document, correspondence, and applications for disability and allowance. |
East | Range: 20 Section: D Shelf: Box Number: 1583 | 150 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1935 | Bettie Smith v. Life & Casualty Insurance Co. | Knox | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff, who had a policy with the defendant, sued to collect $25 in unpaid claims plus a 25% penalty. Plaintiff also had policies with 3 other insurance companies & had filed claims with all of them. Defendant argued that her carrying aggregate insurance of over $7 violated her policy contract with them, & under the terms of the contract they were liable for only the pro rata part. Defendant had paid some of her claims before learning of the other insurance policies. |
East | Range: 8 Section: D Shelf: Box Number: 884 | 114 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1932 | Boyd J. Shipley v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. | Knox | Insurance Disputes |
Bessie M. Shipley was an employee of the Standard Knitting Mills and was enrolled in the group life insurance program provided by said employer through the def. and to which the pla. was the beneficiary. Bessie became ill and died on Oct. 28, 1931 in Knoxville General Hospital. Pla. claims the def., in breach of contract, has refused to payout the said policy. Exhibit materials include correspondence and employment information. Bessie had a 7th grade education and made $0.21 per hour. |
East | Range: 10 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 1457 | 107 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1949 | Betty Clark v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company | Bradley | Insurance Disputes |
Deceased: Bud Clark. Deceased was killed by a gun shot to the head by a Police Officer, Plaintiff is trying to collect on accidental death policy. Exhibits include photo static copies of insurance policy and proof of death, previous case records. |
East | Range: 7 Section: A Shelf: Box Number: 515 | 101 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1939 | Bessie Barrett v. National Life & Accident Insurance Company | Knox | Insurance Disputes |
This was a suit to recover as beneficiary on a policy of industrial life insurance upon the life of Willie Barrett. |
East | Range: 7 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 630 | 199 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1944 | C. E. & P. D. Angel v. Eureka-Security Fire & Marine Insurance Co. | Campbell | Insurance Disputes |
Car insurance dispute. Exhibits include sales agreement, promissory note, insurance policy, post receipts, correspondences, cancelled check, |
East | Range: 7 Section: D Shelf: Box Number: 601 | 155 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1935 | C. R. Taylor v. General Exchange Insurance Corporation | Carter | Insurance Disputes |
C.R. Taylor is sued General Exchange Insurance Corporation on a plea of debt due by action on a fire insurance policy that he had with the company. He claims they have failed to pay him what is owed to him for damages his property sustained in a fire. |
East | Range: 8 Section: G Shelf: Box Number: 960 | 158 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1932 | Carrie Miller v. John Hancock Mutual Life Insurance Co. | Carter | Insurance Disputes |
Plntff., an employee of the Bemberg & Glanstorff Plants, is sued on a group health policy for $1100, the amount of her certificate, plus a $275 penalty. The $1100 was to be paid if the policy holder became permanently disabled, which she has, but deft. refuses to pay. Deft. argues that it owes Miller nothing as her insurance with it had terminated & was cancelled, she had failed to file due proof of her disability as required by the policy, & was not totally & permanently disabled. |
East | Range: 10 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 1434 | 143 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1935 | Cosmopolitan Life Insurance Company v. Maud Colvin & Cosmopolitan Life Insurance Company v. O. W. Helms | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes |
O. W. Helms was driving a car while on business for Cosmopolitan Life Insurance Company when he struck and killed Allen Jordan, of whose estate Mattie Sharp is the administratrix. Helms abandoned the car and reported it stolen. Jordan had been living with and supporting Sharp while married to Maud Colvin. Cosmopolitan attempts to absolve themselves by stating they do not require their employees to travel by car. |
East | Range: 10 Section: H Shelf: Box Number: 1529 | 827 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1942 | Charles A. Monday v. Locomotive Engineers & Conductors Mutual Protective Association | Knox | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff seeks payout of discharge insurance after being fired from his job. Exhibits include membership application and witness statements. |
East | Range: 6 Section: J Shelf: Box Number: 485 | 45 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1917 | Continental Insurance Co. of New York et al.v. R. W. Perry | Knox | Insurance Disputes |
Add. Plaintiff: Fidelity Phoenix Fire Insurance Co. |
East | Range: 7 Section: H Shelf: Box Number: 741 | 4 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | Charles P. Suess v. John Hancock Mutual Life Insurance Company | Carter | Insurance Disputes |
See also box 1556 |
East | Range: 8 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 931 | 89 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1874 | Dr. Thomas D. Meaux et al. v. Southern Life Insurance Company | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Additional plaintiff - Ella LeGrand Meaux |
West | Range: 84 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 41 | 0 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1935 | Delmar Cash v. John Hancock Life Insurance Co. | Washington | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff, who holds a $1500 insurance certificate with def.., is sued def.. to recover this amount. Plaintiff states that he is permanently disabled & unable to work due to "bronchial trouble, lung trouble, tuberculosis of the lungs" & other diseases. He has proven his illness & disability to the deft. in accordance with the terms of the policy, but deft. has refused to pay. Deft. argues that the claim was denied because the policy had not been continuously in force for 1 year as required. |
East | Range: 8 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 850 | 134 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1939 | Dana C. Walker v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. | Hamblen | Insurance Disputes |
Dispute over whether Plaintiff was still covered by Defendant's insurance policy after being laid off. Exhibits include insurance documents. |
East | Range: 7 Section: A Shelf: Box Number: 521 | 88 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1912 | Dave Albritton, et al. v. German Fire Insurance Company | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff: Ned Crenshaw. Case is an effort to collect $1,000 on an insurance policy on the West Tennessee Academy, which was destroyed by fire. Plaintiffs own the property on which the school sat; defendant company says the policy was made out and signed in the name of the school, not of individuals, and will not pay. |
West | Range: 80 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 1081 | 70 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1932 | Dora Fox v. the National Life & Accident Insurance Company | Campbell | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff sues insurance company seeking recovery of $2,500.00 beneficiary benefits on her deceased husband, Clifford Fox, dec. 23 April 1930. Exhibits include insurance documents, policies. |
East | Range: 10 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 1423 | 48 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1920 | Ernest Allen, admr. of Sarah J. Allen et al. v. Joseph H. Cunningham et al. | Davidson | Insurance Disputes |
Additional plaintiff: Charles B. Allen. Additional defendants: United Order of Golden Cross of the World and Local Commandery of the United Order of the Golden Cross |
Middle | Range: 21 Section: G Shelf: Box Number: 148 | 0 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1937 | Ernest Watson v. North Carolina Mutual Life Insurance Co. | Sullivan | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff sued to collect benefits plus penalty due under the terms of an insurance policy that was issued to his first cousin, Vivian Watson, and of which he is he beneficiary. Defendant denies any liability on grounds that the insured stated falsely that she was in good health when she applied for the policy & when the policy was delivered, when in fact she was seriously ill at the time. |
East | Range: 8 Section: J Shelf: Box Number: 1032 | 51 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1917 | Franklin Fire Insurance Company v. S. A. Douglass& wife | Rutherford | Insurance Disputes |
The wife of S.A. Douglass was Arabella Douglass. |
Middle | Range: 21 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 106 | 0 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1886 | Factors Mutual Insurance Co. v. Stewart, Gwynne& Co. | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Andrew Stewart and Andrew Gwynne were partners in the firm of Stewart, Gwynne, and Company. |
West | Range: 83 Section: D Shelf: Box Number: 300 | 308 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1904 | Frank Myers & Mrs. Mattie O. Myers v. E. Nathan & Co. | Shelby | Insurance Disputes | West | Range: 80 Section: A Shelf: Box Number: 1013 | 53 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1934 | Francis W. Miller et al. v. Sovereign Camp, Woodmen of the World | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes |
Case incomplete: Exhibits only. For the rest of the case, consult MT Box 78. Check stubs and insurance policies |
East | Range: 8 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 905 | 308 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1878 | Franklin Insurance Company of Philadelphia, Pa. v. McCrea, Maury& Co. | Davidson | Insurance Disputes | Middle | Range: 20 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 29 | 0 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1939 | Fred Wallace v. Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co. | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes |
Exhibits include insurance documents and certificates, |
East | Range: 6 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 404 | 67 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1911 | F. R. Allen v. German Fire Insurance Co. | Hardin | Insurance Disputes | West | Range: 80 Section: D Shelf: Box Number: 1115 | 44 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1921 | Felix K. Smith v. The Standard Accident Insurance Company | Madison | Insurance Disputes |
Plaintiff is sued for the debt due by policy of health insurance whereby the defendant agreed to insure the plaintiff against loss of time arising from sickness and agreed to pay the plaintiff $60.00 for an operation to fix a hernia. sued for a debt in the sum of $310.70 for the surgery and loss of work as per the insurance contract. |
West | Range: 78 Section: C Shelf: Box Number: 1673 | 17 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1875 | Germania Life Insurance Co. v. Caroline Frasch, admr. of John Frasch, dec. | Davidson | Insurance Disputes | Middle | Range: 32 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 352 | 81 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1887 | Germania Fire Insurance Co. et al. v. R. T. Ross & Co. | Gibson | Insurance Disputes |
Additional Plaintiff: Hanover Fire Insurance Co. Firms insured stock of goods and merchandise belonging to R. T. Ross & Co. for $2500. On 3 Dec. 1882, while policy was in force, firm lost $490 in goods to a fire. Sued when insurers refused to pay. |
West | Range: 83 Section: H Shelf: Box Number: 422 | 101 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1940 | Grover C. King v. Mutual Life Insurance Co. of New York | Greene | Insurance Disputes |
Exhibits include insurance policies and claims documents, correspondence, sales slips. |
East | Range: 7 Section: D Shelf: Box Number: 611 | 416 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1938 | G. Rupert Reynolds v. New York Life Insurance Co. | Knox | Insurance Disputes | East | Range: 7 Section: J Shelf: Box Number: 760 | 184 | Order A Copy | |
View Entry | 1935 | Globe & Rutgers Fire Insurance Co. v. Rhode Island Insurance Co. | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes |
Reply brief only. |
East | Range: 8 Section: B Shelf: Box Number: 818 | 11 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1932 | Glens-Falls Insurance Company v. Twin City Junk Company | Sullivan | Insurance Disputes |
Add. Material in ET 1415. Plaintiff are partners doing business under the firm name of Twin City Junk Company. sued the def. for $1,900.00 for in 1931, the pla. were the owners of a truck on which they held an insurance policy with the defendant against accidents, including fires. The truck was destroyed by fire and its actual value at the time was the $1,900.00, which the policy should cover, but the defendants are refusing to pay. Suing for an additional 25% penalty provided by statute. |
East | Range: 10 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 1439 | 56 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1929 | Geneva Hill v. National Life & Accident Insurance Co., Inc. | Shelby | Insurance Disputes |
Dispute on life insurance policy for Gertrude Sanford, sister of plaintiff. |
West | Range: 80 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 1135 | 27 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1936 | George C. Bass, Jr. v. Aetna Life Insurance Co. | Hamilton | Insurance Disputes |
Under terms of plaintiff's policy with defendant he would be paid $25 per week for life if permanently disabled. On 3 March 1930 plaintiff accidentally injured himself by drinking a small amount of "Jamaica ginger" that contained a "foreign or poisonous" ingredient & suffered "multiple neuritis", resulting in permanent disability. Aetna discontinued its payments after 48 weeks & has not paid in 2 years. Exhibit of ginger extract located in ET Oversize Box 11. |
East | Range: 8 Section: G Shelf: Box Number: 959 | 225 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1933 | George Mason Falls v. the Prudential Insurance Company of America | Unicoi | Insurance Disputes |
On 1 September 1927, the plaintiff and defendant insurance company entered into contract of insurance, $2,000/mo. payments should policy holder become disabled or incapacitated. Plaintiff later developed acute pulmonary tuberculosis, became totally disabled, permanently unable to perform any work. Insurance company failed to uphold their contractual agreement. Exhibits include policy issued through Clinchfield Railroad Co., letter of correspondence. See also box 1582 |
East | Range: 10 Section: J Shelf: Box Number: 1553 | 219 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1890 | Georgia Home Insurance Co. v. C. A. Crunk | Lincoln | Insurance Disputes |
Def. in error was the owner of a two story frame shingle roof home situated on the north side of Market Street in the town of Fayetteville, TN and insured against fire by the pla. in error. Said home was destroyed by fire on March 27, 1890. Def. now states pla. refuses to make payments. Pla. claims a tornado caused the initial damage which led to the fire and believes this releases them from liability. Also see "The London and Lancashire Fire Insurance Co. v. C. A. Crunk," located in MT 892. |
Middle | Range: 35 Section: F Shelf: Box Number: 892 | 91 | Order A Copy |
View Entry | 1874 | Hugh McCrea & Co. v. Nashville Commercial Insurance Co. & Hugh McRea v. Tennessee Marine & Fire Insurance Co. | Davidson | Insurance Disputes |
McCrea sued for $10,000 over seventy bales of cotton that he insured before transporting from Nashville to New York by rail and waterway. However, a fire destroyed Harmon Cotton Compress where the goods were stored, destroying the shipment as well. McCrea hoped to recover the value of the cotton in damages, via insurance. |
Middle | Range: 20 Section: E Shelf: Box Number: 15 | 160 | Order A Copy |